26 October 2026  ·  Policy

What the first S5 appeals say about "physically well-related"

Policy S5(1)(j) is the route outside settlements for an evidenced unmet need, most often for housing, and its key phrase is undefined. Eight decisions issued since 17 August show how inspectors are filling the gap, and one reads unmet need more widely than the two named tests.

Since 17 August, housing outside a settlement has needed a category before it gets the favourable balance. For most speculative schemes the category is S5(1)(j): development addressing an evidenced unmet need that is "physically well-related to an existing settlement" and of a scale its infrastructure can take. Pass it and the scheme should be approved unless the benefits are substantially outweighed. Fail it and the scheme falls to S5(4), where the benefits must substantially outweigh the harm.

The framework defines a settlement. It does not define either half of the gateway. On 6 October the housing and planning minister wrote to the Planning Inspectorate describing the test that follows a pass as "a universal tilt in favour of granting permission". The eight decisions read here suggest the gateway, not the tilt, is where cases are being decided.

The sample

These are eight decisions issued between 10 September and 9 October 2026 that apply S5 to new housing outside a settlement, each read in full. They were found through reported cases, so they lean towards the notable. For scale, the Inspectorate decided 2,144 section 78 appeals in July to September 2026 and allowed 31%. Eight decisions show reasoning, not rates.

AppealPlace and authorityHomesWell relatedOutcome
6009593Washington, Horsham1NoAllowed under S5(1)(d) and (e)
6005108Drayton, Vale of White HorseUp to 31YesAllowed
6005809Kingston Bagpuize, Vale of White HorseUp to 249YesAllowed
6006900Findon, South Downs National Park1NoDismissed
6008253Aston Clinton, BuckinghamshireUp to 66NoAllowed under S5(4)
6009363Brigsley, North East Lincolnshire9YesDismissed, particularly on L3
6009048Needingworth, Huntingdonshire7 to 9YesAllowed
6008560Tattenhall, Cheshire West and ChesterUp to 9NoDismissed

Four readings of "physically well-related"

Adjacency plus consented land. At Needingworth the inspector took account of a 30-home permission to the north, finding the relationship "would be further enhanced". That is consistent with the glossary, which counts land with permission as part of the settlement.

Form. At Tattenhall the site adjoined the settlement "along one side only" and was "an outwards extension and not rounding off". Adjoining was not enough.

Character. At Aston Clinton the site was "very close to the settlement" and accessed from within it, but harm to the character and appearance of the area, and to the village's setting, meant it was not well related. The inspector then allowed it under S5(4) on substantial housing benefits. So harm that failed the site at the gateway was then outweighed under S5(4).

Accessibility. At Findon the site was not well related because residents would "likely be highly reliant on private cars for most journeys, irrespective of the precise distance".

Washington adds a limit. The inspector would not import the location test into the infill category, noting it "only appears within parts 1h and 1j".

The open question for promoters and authorities

Aston Clinton found moderate harm to character and appearance and limited harm to the village's setting, and held the site was not well related. Needingworth found limited harm to character and appearance and held the site well related "notwithstanding the limited harm". Whether character evidence is a threshold argument or a balancing one is still open.

Unmet need is not limited to the two named tests

At Kingston Bagpuize the authority had a five-year supply, by about 88 homes on the inspector's figures, and Housing Delivery Test results of 177%, 193% and 192%. The inspector relied on the words "including, but not limited to", and found that the "very marginal" supply and the evidenced need for affordable housing, with 2,904 households on the register at 31 March 2025, "combine together" to meet S5(1)(j). Three days earlier, at Drayton, another inspector had put the same district's supply at about 4.9 years.

Annex A, paragraph 3 protects a newly adopted plan for five years from one argument only: that the standard method figure exceeds the plan requirement. It does not address affordable housing need. If the Kingston Bagpuize reading holds, a five-year supply narrows the route without closing it. Any High Court challenge must be made within six weeks of the decision, by 26 October.

Passing the gateway is not the end

Brigsley passed S5(1)(j) and was still dismissed. The inspector's reasons were "particularly but not limited to" policy L3: at 6.8 dwellings per hectare gross, the scheme did not make effective use of land, and S5(2) says the benefits are likely to be substantially outweighed where a policy requiring refusal is failed. Poor connectivity and harm to the character of the area also weighed against it. Brigsley shows that low density can be a reason for refusal on an edge-of-settlement site that otherwise qualifies.

Drayton shows the vocabulary still settling. Having applied S5, the inspector concluded that harms "would not significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits", the wording of the withdrawn paragraph 11(d).

What this means for a case

In most of these decisions, location evidence did the work: edge form, enclosure, walking routes to services, and any adjacent allocation or consent. At Drayton and Kingston Bagpuize, supply evidence still decided the route. For an authority, character harm may be best run at the gateway, as at Aston Clinton, though the same case shows S5(4) can still let a scheme through. After Brigsley, density is a live issue on both sides, not a detail to leave for reserved matters.

The Inspectorate published its July to September figures on 22 October. Only six weeks of that quarter fell under the new framework, so the first full quarter will be in the release of 28 January 2027.

Sources

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, National Planning Policy Framework, August 2026, policies S3, S5, L3 and N4, Annex A and the Annex B glossary.
  2. Matthew Pennycook MP, letter to the chief executive of the Planning Inspectorate, 6 October 2026.
  3. Appeal decisions 6009593 (Washington, 10 September 2026), 6005108 (Drayton, 11 September), 6005809 (Kingston Bagpuize with Southmoor, 14 September), 6006900 (Findon, 18 September), 6008253 (Aston Clinton, 24 September), 6009363 (Brigsley, 1 October), 6009048 (Needingworth, 7 October) and 6008560 (Tattenhall, 9 October), via the Planning Inspectorate's appeals service.
  4. Planning Inspectorate, statistical release, 22 October 2026, for section 78 appeals decided July to September 2026.

Does this affect a site you are working on?

Tell us the question. No charge for the first conversation, and no obligation after it.